Thomas Cole (1801–1848) was America’s first major landscape artist. Though he was born in England and spent his formative time in Europe, his identity was as an American nature painter. He was also an advocate and protector of untouched American land threatened by industrial development.
Cole’s father, a small-time businessman, moved his family from place to place in northwestern England. In the process, Cole worked as a print shop apprentice, designing styles of cloth and later making reproductions of well-known paintings. In 1818, the family sailed to the United States, settling at first in the east coast city of Philadelphia. The teenage Cole stayed behind on the east coast as his parents traveled westward. From this point, his career as a largely self-taught artist began.
Cole began to travel and wherever he went — including, briefly, to the Caribbean — he sketched what he saw. He had little patience with cities and distanced himself from them when he could. At the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, he became familiar with new American and European work. But within a few years, he felt ready to head to New York City, where he made lasting contacts in the still small art world, and was able to sell some paintings. And on an 1825 trip up the Hudson River, he found the subject that he would make his own: the American landscape, which he approached as both a mirror of reality and an object of fantasy.
Encouraged, Cole resolved to leave for Europe, a move that would let him see firsthand the art he had known mostly in reproduction. In terms of sales, London, the first stop, was a failure. No one noticed him, but he noticed a lot. He saw England suffering from chaos, with old social structures breaking down as a new industrial elite threatened a traditional wealthy rural class. And he saw artists responding to that. From England he went on to Italy, a more pleasant stay, though it was also suffering its own social issues. Outside Rome, he saw and painted countryside bathed in the hazy sunset light that he had seen and loved in 17th-century landscapes.
When Cole returned to America in 1832 he found it confusing and depressing. Though he had worked hard to leave his poor childhood behind through identification with a cultural elite, Cole found a new America: competitive, commercial, and uncivil — a land of uncontrolled and destructive greed. He was committed to the USA — he became a citizen in 1834 — but left New York City with his wife and children for the countryside. What most disturbed him was the government’s seizure and destruction of natural forest lands. From his house he could see forests being rapidly cut down. Increasingly, he used painting to protest against these developments. Cole chose wilderness, and used the rest of his life to paint it.
One of Cole’s earliest pieces illustrating his dedication to the preservation of nature is The Tree, dated 1823. Done while he was living in the Caribbean, it’s an ink drawing of a single tree. But it is no ordinary tree: although realistically drawn, it looks bizarre, almost resembling some kind of animal, swinging its arm-like branches and walking on its roots.
Cole’s paintings from his Italian trip feature a different kind of countryside. These landscapes focused not on pure and untouched nature, but on the ruins of a long-dead culture. One of his most famous works is a series called The Course of Empire (1834–36). In five separate paintings, it narrates the stages that an unnamed fictional civilization passes through: from forest origins, to rural innocence, to proud flourishing high society, to destruction, to vanishing.
Returning to America, Cole settled on producing and selling landscape paintings. An early landscape, View of the Round-Top (1827), depicts thin clouds in the cool fresh air, a forested mountain, and a river winding in the distance. Paintings such as these were popular and sold quickly for high prices to New York’s new wealthy elite.
A similar image that was far more effective is the single, large 1836 painting titled View From Mount Holyoke (The Oxbow). From a bird’s-eye height we look down at the spot where the Connecticut River, flowing around an island-like mass, creates a question-mark shape known as the Oxbow. The painting divides vertically into two distinct halves. To the left is a wild cluster of old trees and dense vegetation, which looks messy and threatening, but full of life; to the right, flat, treeless, square-cut fields which are cultivated and fertile, but feel bare and bland. In the foreground is a tiny self-portrait of Cole at work. He turns away from his canvas and looks right at us, as if to say: Here are the alternatives that you will face; you choose.
When he died suddenly at 47, in 1848, he was widely mourned. After Cole’s death, respect for his life and work was shown by fellow artists in the form of paintings done in a similar style for just a few years. The most famous was Asher Brown Durand’s 1849 Kindred Spirits, which illustrates Cole and the nature-poet William Bryant engaged in deep discussion in a rugged paradise of New York State forest. Yet, within a few years, Cole was all but forgotten, and it took more than a century before he was rediscovered.